The Breakfast Club: Criterion Collection (Blu-ray)

Review of The Breakfast Club: Criterion Collection (Blu-ray)

The Breakfast Club: Criterion Collection (Blu-ray)

Film Information

Director: John Hughes // Criterion // 97 minutes // Rating: R // 1985
IMDb Information Certified Fresh 89%

Reviewed by: |
Skip to Scores

Plot: What’s it about?

“…And these children that you spit on as they try to change their worlds are immune to your consultations. They’re quite aware of what they’re going through…”

-David Bowie

Plot: What’s it about?

Three decades. Thirty years. That’s roughly 11,000 days. I know I’ve said this before but I’ll say it again – time flies.  When The Breakfast Club came out in theaters I was living, coincidentally enough, in Wheaton, IL (a suburb of Chicago). I was in seventh grade and while not quite the age of the characters in the film, I was able to relate (as were all teens) to what they were going through and what they were feeling. And that is the enduring appeal of this film. Hell, my step sons have both seen it multiple times and they can relate to it. If that’s not the epitome of a great film then I really don’t know what is. Switching gears to John Hughes – well the man was amazing. His movies defined the teen films of the 80’s and there’s got to be at least one that stands out as a favorite. For many it’s this one. I’m a fan of Ferris Bueller’s Day Off, Weird Science, Sixteen Candles and The Breakfast Club but Pretty in Pink never really did it for me. Throw in St. Elmos Fire while you’re at it – filmed the same year with three of the five cast members (playing college graduates instead of high school students) and that’ll just about do it.

Five students find themselves in the last place they want to be – at school on a Saturday. They’re there for different reasons: Brian (Anthony Michael Hall) was contemplating suicide and a flare gun was found in his locker. Claire (Molly Ringwald) skipped school to go shopping. John (Judd Nelson) pulled a fire alarm. And Allison (Ally Sheedy) really had nothing better to do. They’re met by the principal, Mr. Vernon (Paul Gleason) and are assigned to write an essay as to why they were put in detention. As the day progresses, fights ensue but, more to the point, these five seemingly different teens start to let down their guards and get to know one another. They find out that they’re really not that different. Even Mr. Vernon has an epiphany while talking to the school janitor (John Kapelos). And, by the end of the day, their lives are changed forever.

Filmed entirely in sequence, The Breakfast Club is the gold standard which all teen movies will be judged. It’s likely there will never be another film like it. It made stars of the cast that carried them through the 80’s and well into the 90’s. What’s so universally significant about the film is that the message is universal. Every single teen has issues – be it with their parents, friends or both. The movie was able to showcase that in a way that most weren’t able.  The message was simple and also relatable.  This is what John Hughes did best and why this bunch of films are still so admired even today.  I’m sure that anyone reading this review will have seen this film, but if not – by all means…do!  If ever there’s a movie that defines a generation then this has got to be on the short list. Highly recommended.

Video: How’s it look?

When Criterion releases a film on Blu-ray (or DVD), you’re getting the best possible picture that’s available. That’s a fact. More often than not, there is a new restoration done and supervised by key members of the film’s production. Universal released a thirtieth anniversary edition in 2015, however Criterion has done another 4K restoration for this Blu-ray. What immediately struck me was the absence of any dirt, debris or grain. It just looks like a movie that was made recently (outfits, aside). There’s a fine layer of grain that’s been present on every incarnation of the film, but it’s not distracting in the least. The 1.85:1 AVC HD image does sports an improvement over past versions. I’d venture to say that this is the best the film has ever looked on a home video format.

Audio: How’s it sound?

The original mono track is included as well as a DTS HD Master Audio mix. Don’t let the DTS HD Master Audio moniker fool you. While The Breakfast Club does sport a lossless soundtrack, it’s not one that’ll shake the room. Then again, having seen it time and again, we all know that. Certainly this soundtrack is one for the ages with “Don’t You Forget About Me” taking front and center (literally). Vocals are rich and crisp, we can hear every one liner uttered. Surrounds are surprisingly quiet and don’t offer a lot of action, but this has always been a front heavy soundtrack with only a few instances of dynamic audio. It’s a nice-sounding track, but not one that’ll test the limits of your system.

Supplements: What are the extras?

  • Audio Commentary – This commentary track, recorded in 2008, featured actors Anthony Michael Hall and Judd Nelson and this was the same one featured on the 30th Anniversary Blu-ray put out by Universal. Judd Nelson and Anthony Michael Hall contribute and it’s chock full of little tidbits here and there, but they seem to get lost watching the film. It’s not that technical, but rather a look back for the two stars as they watch the film. It’s a nice listen, but nothing mind-blowing is contained.
  • Deleted and Extended Scenes – A selection of scenes are presented from the original 150 rough cut of the film (the movie ended up being 97 minutes). Though the film quality varies, it’s nice (and impressive) to see new scenes to a movie that’s become so familiar to us.
  • Sincerely Yours – This documentary is actually divided up into twelve sections with the actors reminiscing about their roles and working with Hughes (many of the cast members worked with him on several films). It’s a nice look at the film, its influence and what made it all work.
  • Cast and Crew – A series of interviews (the majority of which are three decades old) are featured.
    • Molly Ringwald and Ally Sheedy – Conducted for the Criterion Collection in 2017, Ringwald and Sheedy as they recount how and why they were cast for the film, its success and how it impacted their lives and respective careers.
    • Judd Nelson – Nelson tells of how he was cast, his character and its overall impact on the film.
    • Ally Sheedy – Essentially the same as above, though it’s interesting to compare how she reacted in this feature as opposed to her perspective now.
    • Irene Brafstein – Brafstein was known for her work with actors, specializing in the younger ones. She recalls the cast of this film and the respective challenges that younger actors must go through to continue to get work. Brafstein died of lung cancer in 1998.
    • Paul Gleason – Gleason gives a pretty candid talk about his role in the film (“they offered it to me and I took the part. You gotta take the parts they give you.”), the overall impact of the film as well as his role. Sadly, Gleason died of cancer in 2006.
  • John Hughes – Two audio interviews with John Hughes are presented.
    • American Film Institute (1985)
    • Sound Opinions (1999)
  • Electronic Press Kit – This is a new feature that most probably aren’t accustomed to. As a film reviewer, I’m sent these all the time, but I have to imagine in 1984 these were a different ball of wax. That said, here’s what’s included in the 1985 version of an Electronic Press Kit (EPK).
    • Ensemble Profile – This is similar to a trailer, with some voiceover narration telling about the cast and a brief introduction to the film.
    • John Hughes Profile – Essentially the same as above, only they give Hughes’ resume and label him as an “actor’s director.”
    • Dede Allen Profile – Editor, Dede Allen is profiled as is her impressive work on films like The Hustler, Little Big Man and Bonnie and Clyde.
    • “Youth Picture” – The narrator gives a brief history of “youth pictures” and compares The Breakfast Club to such classics as Rebel Without a Cause, The Graduate and American Graffiti. Looking back, they were correct, but this was made at the time of filming which seemed a tad bit audacious.
    • “Roller-Coaster” – Hughes is once again profiled as he explains how the emotional roller coaster from adolescence to adulthood is profiled in The Breakfast Club and his other movies.
    • Featurette – To be fair to the filmmakers, this is a pretty standard piece and I’m sure they had no idea it’d be featured on a Blu-ray three decades in the future. What we have is Hughes who explains the plot of the film as well as the different personas of the main characters.
    • Theatrical Trailer
  • Today – An excerpt from a 1985 episode of the television show Today features Jane Pauley who interviews with five stars of the film.
  • Describe the Ruckus – Actor Judd Nelson reads from John Hughes’ production notes for the film. It’s a new feature produced for this Criterion Blu-ray and pretty entertaining. It shows how much detail Hughes had about the film and the characters that he wrote.
  • This American Life – The Chicago Public Media radio program This American Life, actress Molly Ringwald is interviewed by host Ira Glass as to what happened the first time she watched The Breakfast Club with her daughter (for the first time). She’s asked what it was like to see the film from the point of view as a parent as opposed to that of a teenager.

The Bottom Line

Three decades after its release, The Breakfast Club remains just as iconic today as it was in 1985. The values and messages contained within the film will continue to speak to generations of teens or those feeling an internal struggle. This was probably John Hughes’s most profound work and certainly an icon of 80’s teen cinema. This 30th edition Blu-ray expands on the previous issue by adding a trivia track and what I feel is a bit better transfer. It’s a draw if you want to “upgrade” to this version if you own the 25th anniversary edition – but this does belong on every shelf regardless.

Disc Scores

Video

The  Breakfast Club: Criterion Collection (Blu-ray) - Video Rating

Audio

The  Breakfast Club: Criterion Collection (Blu-ray) - Audio Rating

Supplements

The  Breakfast Club: Criterion Collection (Blu-ray) - Supplements Rating

Overall

About the Author:

Blu-ray Authority started out in 1999 (then DVD Authority). Since then we've written thousands of original reviews for all platforms, conducted interviews, ran contests and the love continues with Blu-ray, Ultra HD (4K) and more. Follow @blurayauthority